Unleashing Canine Potential
Dogs Are Freethinking, Sentient Beings - Not Machines Triggered by Treats
Discover the fascinating world of canine training and how dogs exhibit remarkable free-thinking abilities that make treat training unreliable.
Dogs Are Freethinking, Sentient Beings - Not Machines Triggered by Treats
Many people misunderstand dogs. They see them as simple animals who only respond to rewards, especially food. But that couldn’t be further from the truth. Dogs are freethinking, sentient beings—capable of incredible intelligence, problem-solving, creativity, and reason.
If you’ve ever truly watched a dog navigate a complex situation, you’ve seen evidence of this. They don’t just follow commands like robots—they think, evaluate, and decide.
As a professional dog trainer in Indiana, I see this every day—dogs making decisions based on their environment, instincts, and relationships—not just based on snacks.
Why Treat-Based Training Often Fails
People assume that if you present a command, offer a treat, and repeat the process enough times, the dog will start obeying consistently. But even if a dog understands the command and the reward, they still have to decide whether they want the treat badly enough to obey.
And here’s the reality: dogs have free will. If the reward doesn’t matter to them in that moment, they will make the choice not to listen.
Positive reinforcement trainers like to argue that dogs will learn for food and perform for food—and they’re right. Dogs absolutely can be trained using treats. But here’s the problem: this form of control is unreliable.
It works—until it doesn’t.
When the dog is hungry, bored, or calm, they may listen. But when distractions are high or danger is present, the treat often loses its power. The training breaks down right when it matters most.
If you’re looking for effective dog training in Fort Wayne or northern Indiana, you need something more dependable than food motivation.
Real Training Shows Up in Real-Life Moments
Who cares if your dog listens when there’s nothing going on? That’s not where training matters most.
The real value of training shows up in high-pressure moments—when your dog is near traffic, around other animals, or in situations where safety is on the line. You don’t need a dog who only listens when it’s convenient—you need one who listens when it counts.
And for that to happen, your dog needs to respect you and trust your leadership—not just follow a bribe.
That’s what I focus on in my board and train programs here in Indiana—developing calm, obedient dogs that respond well under pressure, with or without food involved.
The Substitute Teacher Analogy
To explain this dynamic, I often use what I call the substitute teacher analogy.
Imagine a classroom of kids who are well-behaved with their regular teacher. Then, a substitute teacher walks in. The same kids, the same rules—but suddenly, chaos. The kids haven’t forgotten how to behave. They just don’t care. Why? Because the substitute hasn’t earned their respect or built a relationship.
Even if the substitute knows what the kids are supposed to be doing, they often aren’t given the authority to enforce those expectations. In other words, they’re powerless. But the moment the regular teacher or principal walks in, the room straightens up instantly. The respect is there. The leadership is clear.
It works the same way with dogs.
They don’t need endless treats to behave. They need someone they trust and respect. A leader. A guide. A person whose direction means more than a snack.
Leadership Over Bribery
I’m not special when it comes to training dogs. I’ve just spent the time to understand them. I know how to build relationships based on calm, confident leadership—and I can do it quickly.
If you learn to communicate like I do, if you learn to lead instead of bribe, you’ll experience the same results. You’ll look like a “dog whisperer,” but the truth is, you’ll just be someone who finally understands how dogs really think.
That’s what I teach in my one-on-one dog training sessions and board and train programs across Indiana—especially for families near Fort Wayne, Indianapolis, and surrounding areas.
Pavlov’s Dog (Ringing the Dinner Bell Creates an “Automatic” Response)
Trainers love to reference Pavlov’s experiment—where a dog salivates at the sound of a bell because it’s been conditioned to expect food. But this is often misunderstood. Pavlov’s dogs weren’t choosing to salivate. That was an involuntary response. Training commands like “sit,” “stay,” or “come” are voluntary actions. You can’t ring a bell and make a dog sit against its will. They have to choose it.
That’s the reality of training: dogs must choose to listen. And the sooner we respect them as intelligent beings who make choices, the sooner we can build relationships based on trust, leadership, and mutual respect—not bribery.
In the End, It’s About the Choice
Dogs always have a choice. Training that relies on food assumes you can override that choice with hunger. But real training earns a dog’s choice through respect, relationship, and leadership.
And that’s why I say:
“The true measure of a good dog is not what they will do for you, but what they will do for you when they don’t want to.”
More Insights into Canine Intelligence
Your Guide To Preparing For A Board and Train Program
Your guide when preparing for training...What to Expect When Signing Up for Lee’s Dog Training: Your Guide to Preparing for Our Board and Train Program Quality Over Time You may be a busy person, and you may be worried you don't have time to maintain training...
Why Treat-Based Obedience Training Falls Short – and How Lee’s Dog Training Builds Real Leadership
Discover a training method that builds trust and respect, creating a harmonious relationship between you and your dog. Hi, I’m Lee Seibold, owner of Lee’s Dog Training. For over 11 years, I’ve worked with thousands of dog owners to help them establish genuine control...
“It’s how you raise them.” (Spoiler – not quite!)
Discover effective strategies to turn your aggressive dog into a well-mannered companion. Our proven methods focus on understanding and addressing the root causes of aggression Why Most Dog Training Advice About Aggression is Misleading—and How Lee’s Dog...
6 Ways Lee’s Dog Training Could Save You Over $10,000
and how other programs cost you more...By Lee Seibold, Owner of Lee’s Dog Training Owning a dog brings endless joy, but it also comes with costs—some expected, some not. From food and treats to medical expenses and repairs, the expenses can add up quickly. That’s why...
How It’s Made – Lee’s Logo
Explore the heartfelt journey of how my beloved dogs, Remy and Meeko, inspired the creation of our logo, symbolizing the essence of Lee's Dog Training.Lee's logo is more than just a design; it's a tribute to the two incredible dogs who inspired Lee's Dog Training....
Lee’s Dog Training Touted “Best of the Best”
How Lee has risen above his field as cream of the crop.Lee Seibold, owner of Lee’s Dog Training, has quickly risen to the cream of the crop when it comes to dog behavior and obedience. With awards in 2015 and 2016 for the best dog training business in Indiana, his...
Ready to Build a Stronger Relationship With Your Dog?
If you’re in Indiana and you’re tired of unreliable training methods, my board and train program is designed to transform your dog’s behavior in just one week—without using treats or clickers.
Contact me today to learn more, check availability, or schedule a free consultation.
